The Red Ledger

Review: ‘Isle of Dogs’ is a canine caper that’s ‘ruff’ around the edges

Isle of dogs is

Courtesy of Fox Searchlight Pictures

Isle of dogs is "a film with plenty of good ideas and very few good ways of expressing them."

Joe Cross, Staff Writer

Hang on for a minute...we're trying to find some more stories you might like.


Email This Story






Man’s best friend and Wes Anderson haven’t always been on the greatest of terms. In “The Royal Tenenbaums,” the family dog is run over by Owen Wilson, in “The Life Aquatic,” the dog on the ship is abused repeatedly by pirates, in “Moonrise Kingdom,” the dog is killed with a pair of lefty scissors, and the list goes on. With such a storied history between them, to say the least, Anderson’s new film “Isle of Dogs” may initially seem like a peace offering towards dogs and those who love them, but if that’s the case, then it’s not much of an apology. Not only do the titular canines face peril in various ways, as they’re placed on the aptly-named Trash Island and forced to eat garbage to survive, but also are the subject of a film that couldn’t care less about them or their plight.

It’s obvious why a director like Wes Anderson, notorious for his quirky, diorama-like films and whimsical flourishes, would be drawn to working in stop motion: it’s a medium where he is in full control of every single detail. And from a purely technical standpoint, the film is an absolute triumph. Each of its many dogs are detailed down to the last hair, and it’s clear when watching that hours upon hours of care were put into designing this film, which is precisely what makes “Isle of Dogs” so frustrating. With so much obvious talent on board, one wonders why Anderson and Co. would make such a painstaking effort for a concept as thin and undeveloped as this one.

A prologue lays out a traditional Japanese folk tale and establishes the Japanese government’s firm pro-cat/anti-dog stance. Fast-forward years in the future, and the corrupt mayor of Megasaki city has issued an order to banish all dogs to an island covered in trash. To prove his allegiance to his cause, the first dog exiled is his nephew Atari’s own beloved pup, Spots. In an act of rebellion, Atari flies a tiny plane out to Trash Island and, with the help of a pack of fellow abandoned dogs, sets out on a quest to find his best friend. If “Isle of Dogs” consisted only of this heroic quest, it would make for a fantastic adventure film. But Wes Anderson, no longer making quiet, simple films like “Rushmore,” fills out the rest with pointless subplots and moments that are quirky for the sake of being quirky.

Alternating between scenes that feature our furry friends and a subplot involving political corruption, “Dogs” quickly runs out of ideas and things to say and soon just starts repeating itself. The entire plot involving the impassioned foreign exchange student Tracy (Greta Gerwig) and various scheming scientists is virtually unnecessary, and just one of many truly bizarre decisions that seem self-sabotaging. The major decision that stands out is the film’s setting, a dystopian Japan. Unlike the intricate and developed Trash Island, Anderson’s vision of a futuristic, fictional Japanese city feels undeveloped and barely plays a role in the plot, like a remnant from an earlier draft of the script. I’m sure audiences would receive a Wes Anderson tribute to Japanese cinema and history with open arms, but lazily combining that film with one about a dog rescue mission results in this, a film with plenty of good ideas and very few good ways of expressing them.

While watching “Isle of Dogs,” I wondered who the intended audience is and what the point of all that happens in it is. It’s certainly not the children’s film it was advertised as, as it’s convoluted, occasionally vulgar, and astonishingly grim. It doesn’t even come close to Wes Anderson’s previous foray into stop motion, 2009’s “Fantastic Mr. Fox,” one of the finest (and funniest) family films ever made. At the end of the day, they can’t all be good dogs.

RATING: C-

Print Friendly, PDF & Email

About the Writer
Joe Cross, TRL Reporter

Joe Cross is a senior at Lovejoy High School, a coffee enthusiast, and, most importantly, a film and music obsessive. He can often be spotted wandering...

1 Comment

One Response to “Review: ‘Isle of Dogs’ is a canine caper that’s ‘ruff’ around the edges”

  1. chase on April 20th, 2018 9:27 am

    I think you went into this film expecting a different result that you got, and in your anguish at getting a film that isn’t exactly to your liking, you decided to write a review and attack it because “uwu the japanese city was underdeveloped, it should have been a main plot point” and “uwu how dare wes anderson make a movie more than just a simple hero’s story with dogs”

The Red Ledger values the opinion of its readers and encourages them to discuss its content. All comments are subject to approval by The Red Ledger staff. The Red Ledger does not allow anonymous comments and requires a valid email address. The email address will not be displayed but will be used to confirm your comments. Comments are reviewed as often as possible. Comments with inappropriate content will not be published. Once submitted, comments become the property of The Red Ledger. To see our full Comment Policy, visit https://www.theredledger.net/about-us/policies/

If you want a picture to show with your comment, go get a gravatar.




Navigate Left
  • Review: ‘Isle of Dogs’ is a canine caper that’s ‘ruff’ around the edges

    A&E

    Review: “The Grinch” steals hearts with fulfilling story

  • Review: ‘Isle of Dogs’ is a canine caper that’s ‘ruff’ around the edges

    A&E

    Review: ‘The Nutcracker and the Four Realms’ suffers weak script despite talented actors

  • Review: ‘Isle of Dogs’ is a canine caper that’s ‘ruff’ around the edges

    A&E

    Review: Despite shortcomings, ‘Bohemian Rhapsody’ will rock you

  • Review: ‘Isle of Dogs’ is a canine caper that’s ‘ruff’ around the edges

    A&E

    Art department to host 2nd annual exhibition

  • Review: ‘Isle of Dogs’ is a canine caper that’s ‘ruff’ around the edges

    A&E

    The greatest thrillers of Netflix

  • Review: ‘Isle of Dogs’ is a canine caper that’s ‘ruff’ around the edges

    A&E

    Review: ‘Halloween’ worth the watch

  • Review: ‘Isle of Dogs’ is a canine caper that’s ‘ruff’ around the edges

    A&E

    Review: ‘Venom’ needs less backstory, more action

  • Review: ‘Isle of Dogs’ is a canine caper that’s ‘ruff’ around the edges

    A&E

    Review: ‘Predator’ provides nonsensical and sluggish plot

  • Review: ‘Isle of Dogs’ is a canine caper that’s ‘ruff’ around the edges

    A&E

    Playlist: Sounds of autumn

  • Review: ‘Isle of Dogs’ is a canine caper that’s ‘ruff’ around the edges

    A&E

    Coffee creamery

Navigate Right
The online student news source of Lovejoy High School
Review: ‘Isle of Dogs’ is a canine caper that’s ‘ruff’ around the edges